Technology Trends

Balancing AI Technology with Human Touch

How to balance AI's efficiency and innovation with trusted human expertise. Weigh technology ethics, risks, and when to involve organic ingenuity and intuition.

July 9, 2024

Artificial Intelligence is revolutionizing industries across the globe. AI technology offers the promises of greater efficiency, innovation and fresh business opportunities. However, as a CIO or CTO, determining when to rely on this tech over human expertise is crucial. This weighty decision involves more than just information… It deals heavily with ethics, accountability, and understanding the complex impact AI can have on our society and its organizations.

Below we help you assess when it is best to rely upon and implement AI, and when it might be better to defer to our trusted human resources instead.

Ethical Considerations

One of the first questions everyone must ask is whether it is ethical to replace human jobs with technology. While AI can streamline operations and reduce costs, it's important to assess whether these benefits always justify potential job losses. It's crucial to be honest about whether the AI implementation will create new jobs or merely replace existing ones without generating equivalent opportunities.

Managing AI in a principled manner requires significant effort. This includes ensuring that AI systems are not stealing data, plagiarizing content, or making biased decisions. It takes wisdom and foresight to use this technology in a way that benefits not only your company but also the broader population.

Currently, there are underdeveloped organizations and standards for scrutinizing these decisions properly. As a leader, you must ask yourself if you have the time, expertise, or willingness to hold yourself accountable in a thorough manner. We encourage you to consider keeping the greater good of our world in mind. Take steps to avoid pragmatic decisions with harmful results.

Governance and Risk Management

Integrating principles of governance, risk management, and accountability is essential when implementing AI tools. There will always be unforeseen consequences, much like the unexpected impacts of the Internet, cellphones, and social media on our brains and society. These technologies have unwittingly helped foster social ills such as cyberbullying, polarization, sexual exploitation and widespread screen addictions. Similarly, AI could introduce new threats, making the protection of information and confidentiality more complex. 

Enterprises must act swiftly yet cautiously, setting high standards – knowing that competitors might not impose the same ethical guardrails.

Avoiding Subpar Experiences

Adopting AI without a clear purpose can lead to subpar experiences for clients. As noted by The Economist, "new technology plus an outdated process will only equal an expensive old process, creating a sub-par experience for employees and customers." The real value of technology adoption comes from what the user can do with it, not merely what the technology does itself. 

Many leaders are coming to recognize that AI outputs are best used as drafts, with human oversight required to ensure quality and accuracy. Over time, relying solely on AI without human intervention can lead to both diminished excellence and increased risk of errors.

Bias and Ethical Dilemmas

AI systems can inadvertently perpetuate and amplify biases present in their training data. Ensuring that AI makes unbiased decisions remains a significant challenge. This is especially true in sensitive areas like hiring, lending, and law enforcement. Companies must consider human judgment in scenarios where fairness and ethical considerations are critical. This is the best way to avoid discriminatory outcomes or ethical dilemmas that AI might not navigate effectively.

Complex Decision-Making

AI excels in analyzing large datasets and identifying patterns. It struggles with complex decision-making that requires emotional intelligence, empathy, and deep contextual understanding. 

Human intervention is always preferred in situations where understanding subtle emotions or navigating complex interpersonal dynamics is needed. Roles in customer service, negotiation, or providing advice will benefit from the involvement of more empathetic and intuitive service agents.

Creativity and Innovation

While AI can generate new ideas by remixing existing information, true creativity and groundbreaking innovation often come from human insight. The ability to think abstractly, draw from diverse experiences, and make imaginative leaps is currently beyond AI's reach. Fields that rely heavily on ingenuity and creative problem-solving may prefer human involvement to ensure originality and depth of thought.

In the long run, this will also help us all avoid sounding like echoes of one another, sharing the same information, results and messaging that AI rehashes.

Decisions, Decisions…

As a CIO or CTO, the decision to implement AI should not be taken lightly. We are all going to want to learn how to best balance appreciating the benefits of AI with a concern for our society’s collective wellbeing and the need for more organic input.

Ethical and bias concerns, the complexity of decision-making, and the irreplaceable value of human creativity and innovation are key factors for any leader to consider. AI has the potential to transform businesses for the better, but only when implemented strategically, carefully and responsibly. This cannot be overstated.

By integrating AI in a calculated and wise manner, companies can harness its power while maintaining the human touch that is often essential for success.

Alignment Survey

Interested in what CIO Mastermind could do for you?

* Designed for all IT executives and CEOs, CFOs and Board Members
Thank you!
Please confirm your subscription and add "" to your safe list :-)
Oops! Something went wrong. Please try again.